Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada

3-star beachfront resort in Islamorada with private beach access, zero-entry pool, and complimentary water sports

Amenities & Pools

The Amara Cay Resort Islamorada offers a zero-entry saltwater pool with in-pool loungers and a pool bar serving classic American cuisine and cocktails. Guests have complimentary access to paddleboards, kayaks, bicycles, and fishing poles, plus a free Rum Runner boat taxi that connects to two sister resorts. A small fitness center, a full-service marina with transient slips, and beachside hammocks are available on the property.

Rooms & Suites

Guestrooms at Amara Cay Resort include spacious suites with separate living areas, pull-out sofas, and private balconies that overlook the Atlantic or courtyard. Each room has a flat-screen TV, work desk, and safety deposit box, with vinyl flooring and a mini-fridge provided. The hotel uses a wristband key system for secure and convenient access to the room and resort amenities.

Dining & Entertainment

The on-site Tiki Bar by the pool serves lunch and dinner with a menu that includes fish tacos and flatbreads, and a daily happy hour from 4:00 PM. Inside the lobby, RealCatch restaurant offers breakfast and dinner with ocean views, featuring fresh seafood and locally inspired cuisine. Live local music events and fire pits are set up in the courtyard most evenings.

Family & Activities

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada runs daily family-friendly activities, including tie-dye, sandcastle building, obstacle courses, and foam parties supervised by staff like MK and Emanuel. Children receive a pregnancy pillow upon request for comfort, and the resort provides free cruisers, paddleboards, and kayaks for all ages. A free shuttle runs within 6 km of the property, and the Rum Runner boat services run between the three resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection.

Location & Perks

The Amara Cay Resort is located on the southern end of Islamorada, within walking distance of Lazy Days Restaurant and Bud n' Mary's Marina. The History of Diving Museum is 5 km away, and Anne's Beach is an 8-minute drive. Guests receive a reusable metal water bottle at check-in and can use the hotel's electric vehicle charging station, accessible parking, and pet-friendly policies with pet bowls provided.

• Location: Islamorada, Florida Keys, 5 min from History of Diving Museum
• Rooms: Coastal chic suites with private balconies and ocean views
• Dining: On-site Tiki Bar and RealCatch restaurant with ocean views
• Activities: Complimentary kayaks, paddleboards, bicycles, and Rum Runner boat shuttle
• Wellness: Zero-entry saltwater pool with in-pool loungers and pool bar
• Family: Dedicated kids' tie-dye, sandcastle, and obstacle course activities
• Perks: Access to three sister resorts via free shuttle and boat taxi